Vegan
American
Pizza
Italian

Vegan Italian restaurant offering pizzas, burgers, calzones, wings and more. Open Wed-Sat 4:30pm-7:30pm.


25 Reviews

First Review by TracyWeb

Patanya

Points +118

Vegan
08 May 2024

Moved to New Location

The business has moved around the corner of the building and is now located in Two Ton Tony's Pizzeria. This is the location where they started as a pop up. All of their pizzas are available at this location. You can also build your own pizza. This is the best vegan pizza I’ve had in Rochester. You should note however that the menu is mostly limited to pizza, calzones, fries, vegan wings and a couple of sandwiches etc. One really good change is the hours have been expanded and they’re open every day but Monday. Make sure to check the website.

Pros: Very good pizza. , Quick and easy ordering , Parking available

serena98

Points +1414

Vegan
14 Sep 2023

Superb

Great tasting and good presentation too. Wish I lived closer. I like the swirls they do with the sauce on their pizzas. Definitely try this place out if you’re in the area!

bvankampen

Points +643

Vegan
12 Jul 2023

So good!!!

Tried this place for the first time and it did not disappoint in the slightest! Tasty pizza & garlic knots! Be sure to ask about allergies bc there was no info on the menu

Robinhood_

Points +38

Vegan
03 Sep 2022

Fantastic

The food's amazing! I love the wings and pizza. It's a tad expensive, though.

NickiPT

Points +197

Vegan
02 Sep 2022

Yay!

Was in town visiting family and was so excited to find out about New Ethic! We ordered the Uncle Buck pizza, jackfruit wings, and mozzarella sticks. Flavors were great, I just have a few recommendations to make this place a bit better (in my opinion):

- Pizza crust was dense. If they’re not using double zero flour, they should try that out. Pizza topping flavors were fantastic though!

- Mozzarella sticks: good but freaking humongous. Would honestly be better if they charged less and made them smaller! There’s only so much cheese, vegan or otherwise, that anyone should eat (well, no one should eat dairy cheese but hopefully you know what I mean).

- Jackfruit wings: calling them “wings” is weird, they’re not like wings at all in the way the May Wah ones are (which I buy locally back home). The flavor was really yummy but it had an option for flavor so we picked old bay and it didn’t seem to be flavored that way at all… But it was still delicious! Maybe something more like arroncini (??) than wings.

rmsb812

Points +48

Vegan
14 Aug 2022

Vegan mozzarella sticks 👍🏼

Our group ordered a number of different pizza, calzone, and sub options, all were very tasty! It’s not too often you find vegan mozzarella sticks so those were a big hit with our group as well. Big portions and the calzone held up great for left overs.

angieblah

Points +267

Vegan
31 Jul 2022

Awesome food!

Everything I’ve tried from here has been consistently good! I love that there is a completely vegan pizza shop here in Rochester, especially when a good amount of pizza shops barely even have vegan cheese. Plus it’s pretty close to where I live so I don’t need to drive so far just for some pizza 😆

VeganKH

Points +201

Vegan
28 Jun 2022

Great menu, nice staff, but food was not hot and staff was in slow motion

Great menu, food tasty, but would have been much better if it was hotter. Staff super nice but in slow motion.

Pros: Great menu, Nice staff

Cons: Food not hot, Staff in slow motion

OscarZetaAcosta

Points +58

Vegan
08 Jun 2022

Great, but…

The food is good but the service is intermittently slow and unprofessional.

JoshHyatt

Points +477

Vegan
21 May 2022

Pizza

Overall, a decent pizza place. Good comfort food.

Pros: Pizza and calzone were good, lots of toppings, Mozzarella sticks were the bomb, Milkshakes were delicious

Cons: Long wait for food , Staff, except 1, seemed disinterested in customer, Access was restricted and confusing

M&MSylver

Points +52

Vegan
17 Mar 2022

VEGAN PIZZERIA!

First time customers!

Pros: Vegan pizzeria!!!, The food is decadent!

Cons: None!

KYABUpaks

16 Sep 2023

I suggest you look up the meaning of "decadent". I don't think that's the word you wanted to use.

KadiHarmon

Points +8081

Vegan
23 Dec 2021

A must!!

I love everything about this place. The wings with all the amazing sauce choices, the creative pizza topping combos, and my most favorite, the homemade mozz sticks!! I don’t live in Rochester anymore but on my visits back to see family, I always order from New Ethic. They really capture the western NY pizza and wing vibe I had growing up, without the cruelty! Well done.

Updated from previous review on 2021-12-23

moonbeam_magick

Points +130

Vegan
27 Sep 2021

Phenomenal!

Had an amazing bruschetta chickn pizza, and I can’t stop telling people about the mozz sticks from here! Thankfully was able to order for delivery so I could enjoy a pizza night alongside my family that ordered elsewhere. Highly recommend!!!!

Pros: Their mozz sticks are to.die.for., Delivery! Easy to order online., Easy to customize, many options.

cryptofoodie

Points +146

Vegan
24 Sep 2021

Expensive for the quality

I've tried several things from this place:
Pizza: Extremely mediocre and bland crust, not the best vegan cheese (it's the sort that doesn't melt entirely from the shredded form). 4/10
Milkshakes: I got chocolate, I couldn't tell if there was any chocolate in it. Not worth $7. I've had far better elsewhere. 2/10
Garlic Knots: could have been better but also not bad. 7/10
Calzone: I liked it better than the pizza. 7/10
I think 3 stars is charitable for this price.

Pros: vegan

Cons: expensive, mediocre food

Chase Sage

Points +80

Vegan
18 Sep 2021

Try the calzone with roasted peppers and sausage

Excellent food. Seasoned to perfection. Friendly customer service. Very reasonable prices.

Pros: Variety of toppings , Panini and Calzone , Appetizers

Cons: None

jamieall0ver

Points +79

Vegan
03 Dec 2020

Amazing

I constantly crave calzones now that I’m vegan, & the calzone I got from here blew me out of the water. I’ve had many kinds of vegan calzones, this was by far the best! We also got the pickle pizza, which I wasn’t fully on board with, but that was also incredible. Whatever cheese they use, is delicious. If I lived closer I’d go broke buying food here daily!

Pros: Amazing food, Fair prices

hampton23664

Points +30

Vegan
08 Mar 2020

Not that great.

Would give this one star, but the app won’t allow it. Food was mediocre, staff was self absorbed, and the cheese... not good.

fruitiJulie

Points +3399

Vegan
09 Feb 2020

Great Pizza Restaurant

When you walk in, you may think you are in a 1960’s pizza shop or diner. The pizza shop has vegan pizzas, calzones, shakes, snacks and appetizers. Great pizza with a nice crust. I like how they stuffed the calzone with a lot of vegan cheese. I am removing one star because they don’t give you a lot of sauce on the side for a large calzone and make you pay extra ($.80) for a small container, and no free water (even tap), hopefully they will change that. I recommend trying the oatmilk milkshakes. If you are trying to find the restaurant, the GPS takes you to the parking lot on the side of the building instead of the one in front of it. After you park, you will need to walk left then right from the parking lot, the pizza shop faces the larger street .

Pros: Lots of vegan options

scompter

Points +70

Vegan
19 Jan 2020

Super exciting to have a vegan pizza place!

Lots of fun pizzas to try, or create your own.

CrowMouse

Points +22

Vegan
13 Dec 2019

Authentic Garbage Plates in an Inclusive& Welcoming Environment

Delicious junk food you would find at any pizzeria! I had the Garbage Plate w/Beyond Burger and it was phenomenal. I was very happy to find this kind of food that I could eat as a vegan again.
Great Bonus: signs around the restaurant which emphasize inclusivity no matter your identity, and compost/recycle bins are there to put pretty much everything you use from the restaurant, and almost all of their drinks are in glass bottles! The single-stall bathroom is appropiately all-gender.

Pros: Great junk food, Inclusive Environment, Close to zero waste for customers

Cons: A bit pricey, Semi-Limited Hours so check online ahead of time.

aibababye

Points +145

Vegan
16 Nov 2019

Amazing

Matt has created an amazing space here. Inclusive and all vegan. Delicious food that we love sharing with friends. We can’t get away from the One Justice!

Pros: All vegan, Low Waste, Intersectional

LindaSueTucker46

16 Nov 2019

I have read many good reviews on this board so we decided to give it a try.

RickLooby

Points +19

Vegetarian
15 Sep 2019

Pizza at it's best

Great new establishment a real add to the town not another fast food restaurant.

Pros: 100% Vegan but anyone can get a great meal , Great menu all the pizza choices you can ask for, Meatball sub on a fantastic roll

VeganMelba

Points +20

Vegan
14 Sep 2019

Delicious!

Awesome food and great atmosphere!!

Pros: All vegan, Delicious, Welcoming

droffman

Points +20

Vegan
14 Sep 2019

So good! Best Vegan Pizza Ive had

Long wait but worth it. It’s new so I am not surprised. The pie was amazing.

Pros: All vegan! No concerns about cross contamination , Delicious , Awesome menu choices

TracyWeb

Points +743

Vegan
09 Sep 2019

Vegan pizza!!

I first tried New Ethics’s food a while ago at their first pop up. Wings, pizza, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots... everything was delicious! It’s been refreshing to go to a pizza place and know that everything is vegan. As of writing this, they just recently opened their storefront so the wait time for food has been anywhere from 1-2 hours. I highly recommend calling ahead so you don’t have to stress out about waiting a while for their food. But if you do they also have chocolate chip cookies that you can grab to snack on while waiting😄

Pros: Delicious! , 100% vegan with so many options. , Mozzarella sticks!

Cons: Long wait time




This page has been viewed 7800 times.