Bakery

Vegan owned ice creamery and bakeshop, opened at this space in 2016. Serves old-fashioned sundaes and floats, pies and pastries, plus espresso drinks with plant milk. Offers cinnamon rolls & muffins on weekend mornings. Check webpage for its mobile van schedule & location. Formerly known as Seattle Cookie Counter. Reported closed November 2020.


Venue map for The Cookie Counter
© OpenStreetMap contributors

29 Reviews

First Review by xeight

kem302

Points +144

Vegan
08 Feb 2020

Best desserts!

Desserts here are absolutely amazing! I was only in Seattle for a week and I managed to stop by here 3 times! Each time I got an ice cream sandwich. The ability to choose different ice cream flavors and cookies/brownies lets you get really creative with your ice cream sandwich options. My favorite combination was the double chocolate cookies with mint chip ice cream, but everything is so tasty, so you can’t go wrong.

Pros: Delicious, Friendly staff, Cute atmosphere

TheBearWitchProject

Points +92

Vegan
03 Feb 2020

Fantastic offerings

The Cookie Counter is my go-to for baked goods in Seattle. I’ve never had a bad experience here! Their popsters are about the best thing ever, and I’m also a HUGE fan of their lavender ice cream and banana chocolate chip muffins in particular. I brought my omni family an assortment of cookies and other goodies during the holidays, and while they loved everything, they ended up fighting over who got to finish the cranberry chocolate chip scone haha! I don’t get to make it here too often, but when I do I’m never disappointed by the wonderfully sweet staff and variety of excellent desserts.

cookiem

Points +5888

Vegan
09 Oct 2019

Mmmmm ice cream

So this place obviously has cookies and things, which are sweet and vegan. The best part of it though has to be the ice cream because it's so good! I've been here a couple times, and both times, the best part was the ice cream. They have great flavors like mint chocolate chip, but classic too, like strawberry, vanilla and chocolate. I love that you can get a scoop and split it, so it's like getting a half scoop of vanilla and chocolate, for a little extra cost, but because you know you want more than one flavor but you just came from dinner and can't eat two scoops and a waffle cone!

Oh, yes, they have waffle cones! You can add however many scoops you want to it! There's a gluten free waffle cone, too. Add as many scoops as you think you can handle! Make a milkshake. Oh, so good!

The cookies are ok, but, really, do you want cookies? You can get cookies anywhere! This is really about the smooth, creamy, vegan ice cream. So go. Order a waffle cone. Enjoy!

Pros: All vegan, Gluten free waffle cone, Vegan ice cream!

Cons: No gluten free cookies

OutboundHerbivore

Points +126

Vegan
21 Sep 2019

The Best Desserts

The Cookie Counter is our Seattle go-to dessert option. Their ice cream and cookies are so good! They are known for their ice cream sandwiches. They have a menu with recommended combinations of ice cream flavors and cookies. Or you can make your own! The sandwiches are a lot to eat and very messy! But so worth it!
We usually get a pint to take home since we love their ice cream so much. Everything, including their ice cream and cookies, is made fresh every day in house.

BrendaFairbanksCall

Points +66

Vegan
20 Jul 2019

Super yummy!

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed the pazzouki and S'more cookies that we ordered. The ice cream was delicious as well!! Very yummy desserts!!!! 💟

Pros: Delicious desserts, All vegan choices, Good prices with friendly service

Twill

Points +123

Vegan
07 Jul 2019

My favorite place

I’m always amazed at how good the treats are here. My favorites are the peanut butter rice crispy treats, the peanut butter s’mores cookie, and the lemon matcha cookie. (That one goes well with a scoop of lemon ice cream.)

I’m so lucky to live near the Cookie Counter!

Pros: Best vegan treats ever, Best vegan ice cream

Cons: None!

christytoes

Points +148

Vegan
07 Jul 2019

The best treats

I don't care if you're vegan or not, the Cookie Counter has the best treats in Seattle! Get an ice cream cookie sandwich and you won't regret it. 😋😋😋

Pros: Great food, Great location, Love the atmosphere

ChynaCat

Points +332

Vegan
07 Jul 2019

How did it take me so long to find you?!

I just tried this place two days ago and can’t believe I hadn’t heard about it earlier. All vegan treats!!

Pros: Yummy , Lots of options

chuckisme

Points +42

Vegan
30 May 2019

Great place to gorge on goodies

Super friendly staff and delicious sweets; just the place to pop in on a rainy Seattle afternoon. Have been back again to partake of their sundaes and by golly they are intense!

Pros: Amazing vegan biccies, Stacked sundaes, Thicc-shakes

Skirol97

Points +226

Vegan
30 Mar 2019

Amazing!!!

AHMAZING! Really friendly staff, everything is fresh, the lattes are amazing!

Pros: Great staff, Amazing choices for cookies and ice cream, Always clean and organized

LauraKirol

Points +39

Vegan
28 Dec 2018

Amazing Experience

Cant say enough positive things about this place. The staff was so so friendly and knowledgeable and offered to keep our pint in the freezer while we snacked. The ice cream was perfection. The cookies-lifechanging. They have a pay if forward board and you can buy vegan treats for others.

Pros: Friendly staff, Board games!, Clean bathroom

Mahousloth

Points +129

Vegan
02 Nov 2018

Delish

Lots of toppings (delicious coconut bacon)! The ice cream is good and the bakery stuff is too. Also a selection of clothing and accessories from local artists which is nice! The owner and staff are really sweet and friendly.

Pros: Coconut bacon!!, Supports local artists, Great staff

jhwll08

Points +64

Vegan
28 Oct 2018

Festive flavors for halloween

I had a Frankenstein cookie (chocolate peanut butter) and Goblins delight ice cream (mint chocolate chip). They have fun with the names and the treats taste delicious!

Pros: Really good cookies and ice cream, Great hangout location, Friendly service

Joryh322

Points +49

Herbivore
28 Oct 2018

Delicious treat!!!

The Pink Sugar cookie is hands down my favorite cookie with the s’mores a close second! To be honest I love all of them! I love that they always have themed treats for holidays as well. Just tried the Frankenstein Cookie... soooo good!

Pros: Delicious, All vegan, Friendly owners and staff

Cons: Kinda spendy, but understandable, Parking can be a little tricky

thegrumpytangerine

Points +20

Vegan
01 Sep 2018

Best vegan treats in Seattle

Fantastic ice cream with two rotating flavors per month plus regular staples (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and mint chip). Their cookies are outstanding and they have a great sundae/ice cream sandwich menu if you want to try both at once. The owners and staff are delightful and the shop is adorable and very welcoming. Your non-vegan friends and family will love it too!

StephanieMarkowitz

Points +107

Vegan
29 Jul 2018

Get the strawberry

I literally could eat everything in here, it’s so yummy. The cookies are soft with the perfect chew, and I love their flavors. My personal favorite is strawberry in a waffle cone! Yes!!

Pros: Yummy, So many flavors , Cookies and ice cream

Cons: A little pricey

Saraquel

Points +419

Vegan
14 Jul 2018

Amazing

GREAT ice cream, cookies and dessert in general. Service is good and the place is nice.

josierose

Points +411

Vegan
11 Jul 2018

$5 sundaes on Thursday

Visit on a Thursday for the $5 sundae deal ($5.50 w/ tax) I had the s’mores (special) ice cream with cookie dough and hot fudge toppings. I wish the hot fudge was a little more hot and rich but other than that everything was delicious. The store itself is really cute and there was lots of baked goods as well. It’s definitely worth the trip to visit this store.

HeatherAimee

Points +18

Vegan
15 Jun 2018

Best vegan ice cream in the Seattle area!

Lots of topping choices, and VEGAN WAFFLE CONES. OMG! Lots of vegan cookie options, vegan brownies, and the best vegan ice cream in the Seattle area. Also has a rotating new ice cream flavor... the current one (06/2018) is called "trail mix", with big chunks of oatmeal cookie, peanut butter, and chocolate flecks. They also have banana splits and vegan caramel sauce. AMAZING.

Pros: Lots of choices!

Cons: My stomach is too small to order one of everything

Jojewo

Points +160

Vegan
15 Apr 2018

unbelievable!

Your new happy place! Cute and colorful, friendly staff, and every sweet treat imaginable. And all vegan too! Had warm apple pie with vanilla ice cream - good stuff! Coffee is smooth and hot. We're taking a bag of baked goods home and coming back.

HayleePearson9910

Points +20

Vegan
07 Apr 2018

We Go Here Every Week!

The Team members are amazing, not to mention to Delicious sundaes, baked goods, coffee and s**t ton more that just wants to make you spend your entire paycheck, which is what I do every time!

Pros: Everything

Cons: no parking, long lines at times, can be crowded if you have claustrophobia

Stephaneen

Points +1247

Vegan
26 Mar 2018

My favorite in Seattle!

You guys, this place! My all time favorite place in Seattle is definitely The Cookie Counter. They started as an ice cream truck in 2013 and eventually raised enough funds to open a store front in the Phinney Ridge neighborhood of Seattle. It's entirely vegan with plenty of gluten-free options. My favorite dish is the peanut butter sundae with a s'mores cookie, chocolate ice cream, peanut butter shell and a cherry on top. They have everything from brownies, pop-tarts, pies, cookies and at least five to seven different ice cream flavors. On the weekends, they make cinnamon rolls and waffles. They have plenty of games to play and also outdoor seating during the warm months.

If you're visiting Seattle, add this to the top of your list!

Pros: everything is delicious, gluten-free options, board games

Ksis

Points +1210

Vegan
12 Mar 2018

Literally Heaven

So. Unbelievably. Good.

We got a cookie sandwich with chocolate chip and cookies and cream. It was to die for.

Nastastia

Points +48

Vegan
11 Mar 2018

Heaven

If heaven is on earth this is it. Omg my taste buds are happy. Good sized proportions, great flavors, friendly staff and good seating (had a high chair).

Pros: taste , location, flavors

EmeraldCityVegan

Points +38

Vegan
24 Feb 2018

A must visit place! Delicious sweets!

We visited for the first time last night and we were behind impressed. I got a waffle cone with strawberry and vanilla ice cream, and it was amazing! We also got a bunch of baked goods: brownie, frosted shortbread cookies, frosted sugar cookies, the hot chocolate cookie, that peanut butter crispy masterpiece, the PB s’mores cookie... everything was delicious! Being the first time we weren’t what to expect but we were way happy and will definitely be going back!

Pros: All Vegan, Vegan owned and operated

Cons: parking is scarce on greenwood Ave

XOXO

Points +1836

Vegan
21 Oct 2017

Awesome!!

Gluten free vegan fudgie brownie! Heaven!

MalloryLynneBruner

Points +58

Vegan
17 Aug 2017

Great!

Not having to worry about dairy at all is a huge plus. Super friendly staff and big portions. A little pricey but it's worth it.




This page has been viewed 4795 times.