Take-out
Bakery

A small dessert shop/ bakery with several vegan options in separate cases. Previously called Madame Butterfly Cakes and formerly located in West Babylon. Reported fully vegan November 2023. Open Thu 1:00pm-6:30pm, Fri 12:00pm-6:30pm, Sat 11:00am-6:00pm, Sun 10:00am-2:00pm.


Venue map for Shuga Pie Shop
© OpenStreetMap contributors

9 Reviews

First Review by jayluhx

VeganUnicorn11

Points +17

Vegan
18 Nov 2023

Delicious & unique desserts!

This place makes the best vegan desserts owned by some of the best vegan people I know! I’ve shared them with my non-vegan family members, and they all love them and say “it doesn’t taste vegan.” They have some flavors that are consistent/rotate & others that are seasonal and/or once in a while. Definitely check them out & support them! ☺️

Pros: Delicious, Unique, All vegan

Cons: None

VeganQueenElizabeth

Points +880

Vegan
01 Oct 2022

Amazing !!!!!

Please go get some Shuga Pies ! Best dessert hands down. It will satisfy all your cravings. Check out their social media for flavors of the day and seasonal flavors. Not to mention the owners are awesome !! I am obsessed and I have to say my favorite is the rainbow cookie.

Pros: All vegan

Ramy94

Points +134

Vegan
07 Apr 2021

Best desserts ever

The owners are extremely nice and they have so many delicious flavors to choose from. I no longer live in the area but when I'm back I make sure to stock up. Support this amazing business!

Pros: So many flavors, Friendly owners

Cons: None

prlady13

Points +1114

Vegan
04 Apr 2021

Yummy desserts

These little cake sandwiches are delicious and filling! Love how they offer so many different flavors. Very friendly service too. On our first visit, it took us a few minutes to find it since the shop is in a weird spot. It’s not visible from the street like the other store fronts, it’s down an alleyway. But easy to access from the public parking lot.

kimbe313

Points +192

Vegetarian
04 Apr 2021

Delicious Whoopie pies

I have been wanting to try this place for months and finally made it! I got the strawberry lemonade and it was delicious! The cake part was so soft, and the cream was decadent. I wished I had gotten more flavors to try, but I just need to go back!

Pros: All vegan! , Delicious

ErinOFal

Points +85

Vegan
25 Jun 2020

Get itttt

Okay first off the owners are SO NICE- personable, funny, friendly. Second- the vegan desserts are SO GOOD. The pastries are my favorite as it’s hard to find around here. The prices are super reasonable as well

Pros: Lots of vegan options , Great staff, Good prices

kelsey244

Points +25

Vegan
22 Feb 2020

Delicious

A cute little spot with lots of vegan options for baked goods. Be aware the location is out of the way and it feels like you’ve made a mistake until you walk inside. Not a bad location, just in an odd spot. Definitely recommend tho!

Pros: Half of the items were vegan, Wonderful customer service

Cons: Location

RebeccaSullivan

Points +4155

Vegan
23 Jan 2020

Amazing

Had an incredible cake for my mom’s birthday. Probably one of the, if not the best vegan chocolate cake I’ve ever had.

jayluhx

Points +1462

Vegan
09 Mar 2019

Delicious desserts, great owners!

This is one of my favorite places to get dessert on the island. The owners are seriously so sweet and their desserts are affordable and top notch. Satisfies my sweet tooth and they have something for everyone!!!

Pros: Affordable , Super sweet staff/owners , Local business

Cons: NONE!!!




This page has been viewed 0 times.