Typical Mackinac Island fudge and sweets. Has one vegan fudge. Open Mon-Sun 9:00am-10:00pm.
© OpenStreetMap contributors
-
7245 Main St, Mackinac Island, Michigan, USA, 49757
-
Loading...
-
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 14 Aug 2023 by geometric-noise
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business -
Added by emmawin on 07 Aug 2015
-
-
37 Reviews
First Review by emmawin
TheRootedVegan
Points +54
Vegan fudge - Edit
The fudge was deliciously vegan
Read moreCons: Vegan fudge can only be found on the island
Guest
cowsandcarbs
Points +64
Happy they have an option - Edit
Really good vegan chocolate fudge and happy they have a dairy-free option. Too bad it wasn’t advertised or in the display case.
Read morePros: Yay for vegan option
Cons: Wish there were more flavors
Guest
courtpline
Points +1182
Chocolatey - Edit
I'm not a huge chocolate fan, but my husband said he preferred Ryba's chocolate fudge to Sanders.
Read moreGuest
Plant Powered Eater
Points +515
Good Vegan Fudge - Edit
When we visited, the only available flavor was chocolate. However, it was quite good, & we were happy to buy some! You need to ask for the vegan fudge, as we did not see it on display. We heard that vegan peanut butter fudge is available elsewhere.
Read moreGuest
KatieKaz
Points +20
Just Okay - Edit
Was not on display and kept in a tote. Tasted okay but was like a thick brownie. Family who are not vegan said it wasn't too camperable.
Read moreGuest
EverydayTastiness
Points +2723
Vegan fudge - Edit
Vegan fudge is not in the case. Ask for it. All four locations on main street have it. It's very fudgey and delicious. Sanders fudge was more like chocolate candy, very firm vs the dark chocolate soft fudge texture.
Read morePros: Four locations
Cons: Have to ask for the vegan, not in the display case
Guest
bicycleben
Points +172
Sanders is better - Edit
Fudge was way better at Sanders, plus they have other options!
Read moreGuest
egst
Points +41
Happy they have an option - Edit
The nondairy fudge is in a Tupperware of shame in the back, you have to ask for it and know it's there. I think Sander's fudge is more fudgy (but didn't quite set up all the way), and this fudge tastes like a particularly under baked brownie
Read moreGuest
JonathanBrant
Points +302
I’m glad there is an option! - Edit
As a vegan, it’s great to be able to get something that everyone else goes to Mackinac Island for. However, I’ve had better fudge! You can tell they use cocoa powder instead of melted chocolate as it’s a bit chalky and the texture is not as melt in your mouth as dairy-based fudge. I think a peanut butter option would be fantastic.
Read moreGuest
AaronWissner
Points +135
Excellent vegan fudge, introduced in 2021, yummy - Edit
it is so popular that is the avoeite of many of the employees, and generally considered tastier than the two vegan fudges at Sanders
Read morePros: excellent flavor, very smooth, individually wrapped, two sizes, Ask for it, it's behind the counter at all 4 shops
Cons: only one option
Guest
madzzzk
Points +46
Dairy Free Fudge - Edit
I enjoyed other vegan fudge that was on the island, but never a disappointment when a place surpisez you with vegan options!!
Read moreGuest
jbryan21
Points +162
Better vegan at Sanders - Edit
Ryba's vegan fudge is made from coconut oil and is a bit weird. Sanders fudge shoppe also has vegan (soy based) fudge and it's delicious! HappyCow won't let me add a review for Sanders unfortunately.
Read moreGuest
peteycards
Points +1821
The one vegan fudge is fine, not great - Edit
Double chocolate vegan fudge is fine. If you want fudge, get it. If you require something delicious, you'll be disappointed.
Read moreGuest
irplonk96
Points +2936
Really good fudge - Edit
I tried the vegan fudge from Zak & Mac, and it was awful, so I didn't have high hopes for this one, but it was really good. Usually I find fuge too sweet, but this one was more chocolate-y like a brownie. I highly recommend getting some.
Read morePros: So many locations
Cons: Expensive
Guest
TawnyConnerCleveland
Points +421
Vegan fudge - Edit
So fun to have a fudge treat that is vegan!
Read morePros: Delicious , Vegan, Friendly service
Cons: Not cheap
Guest
nicolevidak
Points +293
Vegan fudge! - Edit
I was thrilled to get fudge on Mackinac Island. It's pretty good fudge too although I wonder how fresh it is. It's not with the rest of the fudges behind the glass so you have to ask for it. They keep it in a box on a shelf behind the counter.
Read morePros: Happy to have vegan option on MI!
Cons: Only one option - regular chocolate fudge
Guest
Teddyak1
Points +113
Good vegan fudge - Edit
As of August 2021 there is still vegan fudge and it's delicious. Only one flavor, fudge flavor.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2021-08-11
Guest
MichelleSapsara
Points +46
Yummy treat - Edit
The vegan fudge was yummy. The staff helpful.
Read moreGuest
cjzhz
Points +32
Vegan fudge - Edit
Finally I get to relive my childhood via fudge minus the dairy. Bought four pounds today and going back to grab some more tomorrow! 😅
Read morePros: FUDGE!
Cons: Only one flavor! I hope they eventually expand.
Guest
veganinvegas
Points +370
VEGAN FUDGE! - Edit
2020 Update:
Read moreVegan fudge not eligible for mail orders, as they ONLY make it during the summer. :(
Earlier:
I travelled almost 2,200 miles from Nevada to Mackinac Island. Just for the vegan fudge. I haven't had fudge for almost 25 years. I stumbled into the store and got a sample. OMG. Sheer bliss.
Only vegan flavor is dark chocolate. Life can't get better than that. I didn't care how much it cost. Between 2 stores, I bought 6 POUNDS! That should last me a while😄
I just emailed their office to thank them for making the fudge. Hopefully, that will show that vegans want junk sweets and won't discontinue it :)
Updated from previous review on 2016-08-11
Pros: VEGAN FUDGE :)
Cons: Only one flavor, More expensive than other flavors
Guest
Cas.
Points +36
Vegan Fudge - Edit
The vegan fudge is delicious! I wish they had more flavors!
Read morePros: Delicious Vegan Fudge
Cons: Only One Flavor
Guest
LarryHagan
Points +26
Vegan Fudge - Edit
Best fudge in the world (my opinion) gets a vegan fudge option.
Read morePros: Vegan Chocolate Fudge , Friendly, Great fudge overall.
Guest
gracielizmill
Points +170
Fudge! - Edit
It was so nice getting to enjoy fresh fudge in Mackinaw!
Read morePros: Tasty , Smells amazing , Kind service
Guest
riri444
Points +48
Good vegan fudge - Edit
I loved the vegan fudge!!!
Read moreGuest
Eyes2cry4
Points +30
Vegan Fudge - Edit
They have some of the best Vegan fudge I’ve ever had. They’re limited to chocolate in flavor but it’s so good that it doesn’t matter.
Read morePros: Incredible flavor
Cons: Only one flavor
Guest
McMallory
Points +2280
Omg - Edit
Can’t remember the last time I had fudge. It’s wonderful.
Read moreVegan fudge isn’t displayed but ask and ye shall receive.
Guest
Pagan
Points +212
Only place we found vegan fudge - Edit
Offers vegan fudge. Still couldn’t find vegan ice cream on the island.
Read morePros: Nut-free vegan fudge
Cons: Offers only one kind - chocolate fudge
Guest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 7931 times.