Vegan-friendly
Lacto
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. In early-2018 this shop began offering several vegan pizzas by the slice or by the pie to-order. Example of choices include sunflower seed cheese on pizza, margarita pizza, and vegan truffle cheese with alfredo sauce and caramlized onion. Open Mon-Sun 10:30am-12:00am.


Venue map for NY Pizza Suprema
© OpenStreetMap contributors

108 Reviews

First Review by evahelgad

Breda

Points +420

Vegan
12 Nov 2019

About 6 vegan slices to choose from

Ordered the Newyork regular slice which was just pizza sauce and vegan cheese and it was so good. the vegan cheese was creamy and the base light and crispy. About 6 different slices to choose from which is a lot for a non vegan place that’s been around 40years.

Pros: Really good newyork style pizza , Good simple ingredients

dbader13

Points +2348

Vegan
11 Nov 2019

Several vegan pizzas by the slice!

I love coming here for a quick and delicious vegan slice of pizza. There's always about 6-8 choices! Yum!

Elliebecomesthedream

Points +197

Vegan
03 Nov 2019

Would give 5/5 if I could

The pizza here is really good. They have 4-5 vegan options and the cheese is tasty.

Pros: Several vegan slices to choose from

JenniferPVegan

Points +18

Vegan
23 Oct 2019

WOW! Great vegan pizza

I got a slice of the vegan margherita pizza here and was blown away by the flavor. The house made cheese is one of the best vegan cheeses I've had on a pizza. Would give 5 stars but Happy Cow only allows 4 max for restaurants that aren't fully vegan. One of the best vegan pizza's I've ever had.

Made with an organic nut free, soy free, artisanal sunflower seed vegan “cheese”. A thin crust topped with generous dollops off fresh plum tomato sauce. Finished off with imported EVOO from Italy, oregano and fresh Basil.

Pros: vegan options, authentic NY pizza

exaltedflesh_

Points +269

Vegan
03 Oct 2019

Favorite vegan pizza in NY

Although this isn’t a vegan establishment, this is easily one of the best vegan pizzas I’ve ever had. They usually have 2-4 vegan options per day.

Poundie

Points +15693

Vegan
30 Sep 2019

Good vegan pizza

This is a top-rated pizza place with a bunch of vegan options--not just "no cheese pizza," but slices with vegan cheese and vegan faux-meats (there were five separate vegan options when I stopped by). It is next to a Flix but stop and fight by Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. This is a very traffic-filled, busy spot of NYC that I avoid unless I have to be nearby--but if you are in the area and like pizza, this is a good place to check out.

Updated from previous review on 2019-09-30

Pros: Good vegan pizza

Cons: Not super-healthy., Trafficy part of NYC

VeganNole

Points +223

Vegan
01 Sep 2019

Amazing Vegan Pizza

Really good vegan pizza and they use ese Ché vegan cheese for their vegan pies, which is a local NYC company that makes their cheese from sunflower seeds. It is so freaking good! Even your omni friends will love it. Much better than the usual Daiya. I definitely recommend it!

Pros: Unique vegan pizzas , Quality ingredients, High quality and natural vegan cheese

Cons: Expensive, Only offers one size for vegan pies

CamilaSilvaL

Points +6554

Vegan
28 Jul 2019

Best pizza ever

I tried the white truffle and the Margherita pizza and they were sooooo good! 6 dollars per slice (HUGE slices!) and a really nice and close atmosphere.

KGinTn

Points +200

Vegan
27 Jun 2019

Great thin crust vegan pie!

Had a slice of vegan spinach and another slice of margherita pizza. Excellent taste and the crust had just the right crispness. Good late night find after a show.

Pros: Multiple vegan options , Loved the crust

rusty728

Points +45

Vegetarian
30 May 2019

INSANE FOR VEGAN PIZZA

They have 3 vegan pizza options: the margarita, veggie medley, and artichoke Alfredo. The veggie medley is more of a classic vegan pizza, still good, but the margarita and artichoke are truly amazing! They taste just like regular cheese pizza. I thought going vegan meant I was no longer able to partake in the beauty and deliciousness of pizza. This place makes that impossible. It’s Insanely good. You feel like you’re taking part in the joy of New York pizza. I haven’t found better vegan pizza than this! I knew it was going to be good when the non-vegan cashier said “oh the artichoke one is good, it’s vegan, but it’s good”.

Pros: 3 vegan options - amazingly good , Vegan pizza by the slice! , Nice employees

Cons: Can get busy

dianarbol

Points +100

Vegan
23 May 2019

Nice slice

Three vegan options: Vegan Margherita, Vegan White Truffle Ash Brie Pizza, and the Veggie Medley No-Dairy (listed as "Vegan-Friendly"). I had the last remaining slice of the Vegan Margherita for $6 (whole 18" pies are $40) and it was pretty good. Not the best vegan pizza I've ever had - very tomato-heavy and light on the sunflower seed cheese - but it's nice to be able to grab a single slice.

Pros: Line moves quickly

Cons: Expensive

ssluchansky

Points +546

Vegan
09 May 2019

Good vegan NY pizza options

The line can be long and, on two occasions, they lost track of my orders and burned my pizza so I had to wait to have another slice heated. But, the vegan options are very good, especially the Vegan White Truffle Ash Brie Pizza, which is creamy and quite tasty. They typically have the Vegan Grandma, which uses a nut-free, sunflower seed-based cheese with lots of vegetables. During the very busy lunch period, getting a table can be difficult.

Pros: Several very good vegan options, Menu states some organic ingredients

Cons: A little pricy (vegan items: $6/slice), During busy times, can be wait for a table

imogenmichel

Points +2693

Vegan
14 Feb 2019

No vegan pizza :(

I came here today to find they had no vegan pizza at all. The staff were rude and completely unhelpful; they even told me a vegan one would be ready in 20 minutes but even after waiting for 25 mins that had nothing. Really disappointing.

OliviaMarie

Points +167

Vegan
04 Jan 2019

Tasty

Really helps satisfy your craving for classic pizza. Excited to go back and try their new flavors.

Pros: Seating area and bathroom

Saregreenbean

Points +86

Vegetarian
05 Dec 2018

Real family run New York Pizza

I highly recommend this place, would have rated 5* if happy cow allowed. Real proper New York pizza. There’s three vegan options including vegan margarita and a truffled ash one which was delicious. They have thin and thick style pizzas

Pros: Three vegan options , Lovely family run business with friendly staff , Very reasonably priced

HadaraSlok

Points +32

Vegan
21 Nov 2018

Best vegan pizza I’ve ever had. This pizzeria has been around since 1963.

i’m allergic to nuts and soy ! so thankful the vegan cheese does not have anything but some flower seeds.

Pros: three different pies vegan pies . , Friendly, Clean

Cons: It’s too hard to choose which slice you want !

DougCohen

Points +20

Vegan
21 Nov 2018

Spinach Artichoke Truffle Brie Pizza

Yesterday after a long day of driving in traffic, I stopped into NY Pizza Suprema, which is a stones throw from MSG. In the window they had a new pizza... With vegan Brie cheese! It was absolutely delicious - best slice I’ve had since going vegan!

Pros: Clearly labeled vegan options, Friendly atmosphere for all humans, Super quick service

Cons: Only two vegan pies available, Long line

midorigreen

Points +363

Vegan
03 Nov 2018

Great pizza and atmosphere

Clearly labelled pizza by the slice. It was so good I was tempted to order an entire pie but wanted to try the different flavours. Worth a visit.

DannyBelmont

Points +18

Vegan
28 Oct 2018

No vegan pizza by the slice!

No experience because they didn’t have vegan pizza by the slice.

Cons: They don’t have vegan pizza by the slice

themuppetlibrarian

Points +2831

Vegan
25 Sep 2018

Delicious NY Pizza

The real deal - ny pizza by the slice. Conveniently located by madison square garden and Penn station

Worldvegkitchen

Points +1307

Vegetarian
24 Sep 2018

Best pizza in NYC!!

I discovered this place due to its proximity to penn station. 5 stars for this pizza! They even have a vegan pizza that was very delicious. Tons of vegetarian pizzas. This is the New York experience for sure!

sarahssoares

Points +831

Vegan
21 Aug 2018

Tasty pizza

Near Madison Square Garden and Times Square, traditional pizzeria that sells slices, with some vegan flavors. We ate 3 of the 4 vegan flavors and approved, very delicious pizzas.

srf

Points +327

Vegan
05 Aug 2018

Great vegan pizza!

I was so excited to find a place offering vegan pizza by the slice close to Penn station. And it was great!

MMC

Points +279

Vegan
19 Jul 2018

Vegan slice is the new “regulah”

This is a favorite of NYC Vegan groups so I had to try all the vegan options. Super nice staff treated me to a complimentary slice of “Grandma” - very neighborly!

Hippicat

Points +138

Vegan
15 Jul 2018

Loved it!

Two vegan pizza choices sold by the slice. I had the vegan margharita and it was great!

Pros: At least two options by the slice

hollywoodtx

Points +57

Vegan
17 Jun 2018

AWESOME

Multiple vegan options!

Pros: 4 vegan options

evahelgad

Points +53

Vegan
04 May 2018

Couldn’t tell this a apart from a non vegan pizza!

Really awesome pizza. Highly reccomend the vegan margherita




This page has been viewed 0 times.