Vegan-friendly
Lacto
American
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. In early-2018 this shop began offering several vegan pizzas by the slice or by the pie to-order. Example of choices include sunflower seed cheese on pizza, margarita pizza, and vegan truffle cheese with alfredo sauce and caramlized onion. Open Mon-Sun 10:30am-12:00am.


Venue map for NY Pizza Suprema
© OpenStreetMap contributors

102 Reviews

First Review by evahelgad

charlie-bird

Points +812

Vegan
21 Nov 2021

Real NY pizza, vegan

You can buy pizza by the slice or the whole pie.
Several vegan options, using vegan cheese.
It's authentic real NY pizza, I'd been missing that since turning vegan and this place delivers! My go to is the New York regular pizza, the classic NY pizza.
Prices are a bit expensive but it's worth it

clarebear9

Points +888

Vegan
30 Oct 2021

4 vegan pizza options.

You walk in and immediately see the 4 vegan pizza options. We got all of them but at least get the white ones. So good! QUICK in and out. Table to sit. Very nitty gritty classic NY pizza place.

Pros: QUICK service, Vegan options first thing you see, White pizzas delicious

paypar

Points +800

Vegan
28 Sep 2021

Quick vegan slice near Penn

I wanted to try the vegan options from here and grabbed one of each of the vegan options. The slices are super thin and crispy so not too heavy. $6 each. They hit the spot but nothing you need to go out of your way for. Solid!

Pros: Some vegan options, Close to Penn (31st and 8th), Indoor seating and takeaway

Cons: Not a cheap $2 slice

GracefulVegan

Points +172

Vegan
30 Aug 2021

Great Pizza NY Crust!!!

We had the NY slice plus one with cashew cream that we added. We also had the Alfredo pizza and Grandma. All were excellent. We’re all (4 of us) pretty picky about pizza and feel like this place hit the mark.

drquayle

Points +738

Vegan
22 Aug 2021

Vegan White Slice

Yuuuuummm. This is one of the best vegan slices I've had. House made vegan cashew cheese instead of store bought "cheese" (which I usually don't love).

Pros: So good!

Cons: Single slice was $7

nshaff3r

Points +201

Vegan
03 Aug 2021

Really good pizza and lots of options

Great pizza, and I was very surprised by the amount of vegan options!

Pros: Lots of options , Great pizza, Fast

Cons: A bit expensive

StefanieJoann

Points +180

Vegan
01 Jul 2021

Amazing vegan pizza!!

Coming to the city trying hard to get back on my vegan journey I thought would be a struggle because of the pizza. I was wrong!! This gives me the exact same happy tummy non vegan NYC pizza used to give me, and reminded me that vegan food is delicious!!!

Pros: Lots of vegan options , Delicious!, Good prices

lise.nox

Points +235

Vegan
19 May 2021

the best vegan pizza i’ve ever had

it was my first time getting new york style slices and i was not disappointed. their vegan options are amazing. i had the vegan regular and the vegan white pizza and they were both SO delicious. i’ve never had such good vegan pizza before and i’m picky with my pizza. finally a non-vegan place who understands that vegan pizza doesn’t mean pizza with veggies!

Pros: amazing vegan options, big slices

dhall22

Points +410

Vegan
17 Apr 2021

Solid vegan pizza option

I've eaten here several times and have always been satisfied with their vegan pizzas. The most recent time (April 2021) they had 4 vegan slice options. My favorite is probably the vegan alfredo - despite the name, it's not too heavy. I have yet to order a custom pie but you could order all kinds of different vegan options. The slices aren't cheap - 5-7 bucks for the vegan ones - but it is right by Penn Station, open late, and always moves quickly.

Pros: Dependable vegan slices, Open til midnight, Fast service

Cons: A little expensive , Lots of meat

TaniaAranda

Points +164

Vegan
20 Mar 2021

Deliciosaaaas

Enorme pizzas, deliciosas. ❤️ no son ingredientes extraordinarios pero saben hacer muy bien sus pizzas

Pros: Tamaño , Sabor , Atención increíble.

Cons: Costoso, Ingredientes comunes y sencillos

FillyBaby

Points +22

Vegan
29 Jan 2021

Horrible, nasty, & burned Vegan pizza

I had to catch a train at New York Penn Station, so I called ahead to order 2 slices of their Vegan Truffle & Alfredo pizza. I paid with my card so all I had to do was pick it up. Each slice was $7, which I didn't mind because of their reviews. Picked up the pizza left to catch my train. Grabbed a slice, took a bite & it was HORRIBLE 🤬!!!!!! The pizza was VERY DRY & BURNED🤬IT WAS DISGUSTING. I WILL NEVER BUY PIZZA FROM THEM AGAIN, NOR WILL I RECOMMEND ANY VEGAN FAMILY TO BUY PIZZA FROM THERE. MIND YOU THE VEGAN SLICES WERE THE MOST EXPENSIVE SLICES THERE!!! SCREAMERS PIZZA IN BROOKLYN IS THE BEST VEGAN PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD. If you're ever in Brooklyn and you want some Pizza go to Screamers you WON'T be disappointed.

Pros: PIZZA IS NASTY!!!!!!!!

Cons: Expensive

JessyPerez

Points +60

Vegan
27 Oct 2020

Slammin’

Great vegan options! Went with the plain Jane vegan cheese and it was delish! Thought it was a bit expensive when I ordered a $40 pie. But it’s LITERAL New York sized pizza’s in a pie. So it was worth it! Got full off 2 slices 😹🙃

jayluhx

Points +1462

Vegan
06 Jul 2020

Should have 5 stars!!!

Best pizza in NYC!!! Open late so perfect after a night of happy hour or what not. Definitely worth the $!! Highly highly recommend

AmyKC

Points +248

Vegan
09 Mar 2020

Great Pizza

This was our first NYC Pizza as Vegans (previously veggies)... this pizza really hit the spot. Will be visiting again during our trip. Seated area clean and tidy. Staff helpful. Service was efficient.

Pros: Lots of options , Great taste

Cons: None

The London Vegan

Points +2265

Vegan
09 Mar 2020

Great NYC style pizza

The perfect place to live out your NYC dreams with the locals. Really old school inside, classic by the slide New York traditional pizza place with lots of great vegan options

DougK

Points +883

Vegan
29 Feb 2020

Awesome pizza

Traditional large slices of pizza with six or seven vegan options. Really great NY pizza.

Pros: Multiple vegan pizzas, By the slice or pies, Delicious

Cons: Probably cross-contact between vegan & non-vegan

blipp

Points +149

Vegan
11 Feb 2020

Excellent vegan pizza

I took three different vegan slices; excellent dough and great taste!

BeckyBrooks

Points +570

Vegan
19 Jan 2020

Best vegan pizza in Manhattan

The cheese they use is artisanal and like nothing else I’ve ever had. Right near Penn Station. Great place to bring non-vegans.

Pros: Great vegan cheese, Old school pizza parlor vibe, Convenient / near Penn Station

Cons: Staff always ignores me when I’m waiting to order

gsteiner

Points +380

Vegan
19 Jan 2020

Good vegan options

There were about five vegan slice options when we ate thete. We had Alfredo, upside down, and Sicilian slices. All were good.

OmarJohnson

Points +102

Vegan
19 Dec 2019

best vegan pizza no lie

no lie, they have the best vegan pizza i tasted in my life. they only have three vegan pizzas. truffle ( my fave), margarita, and plain cheese. sometimes they have the impossible pizza but it is very elusive.

KaitlynnGill

Points +1477

Vegan
17 Dec 2019

Vegan slice

AWESOME! A year ago I rated this place 3 stars but I’m updating to 4. So good! Vegan White pizza is amazing. I’m coming back for sure. So convenient next to Amtrak and Pennsylvania station

Pros: Several vegan Za sliced, Convenient

Breda

Points +420

Vegan
12 Nov 2019

About 6 vegan slices to choose from

Ordered the Newyork regular slice which was just pizza sauce and vegan cheese and it was so good. the vegan cheese was creamy and the base light and crispy. About 6 different slices to choose from which is a lot for a non vegan place that’s been around 40years.

Pros: Really good newyork style pizza , Good simple ingredients

dbader13

Points +2260

Vegan
11 Nov 2019

Several vegan pizzas by the slice!

I love coming here for a quick and delicious vegan slice of pizza. There's always about 6-8 choices! Yum!

Elliebecomesthedream

Points +197

Vegan
03 Nov 2019

Would give 5/5 if I could

The pizza here is really good. They have 4-5 vegan options and the cheese is tasty.

Pros: Several vegan slices to choose from

JenniferPVegan

Points +18

Vegan
23 Oct 2019

WOW! Great vegan pizza

I got a slice of the vegan margherita pizza here and was blown away by the flavor. The house made cheese is one of the best vegan cheeses I've had on a pizza. Would give 5 stars but Happy Cow only allows 4 max for restaurants that aren't fully vegan. One of the best vegan pizza's I've ever had.

Made with an organic nut free, soy free, artisanal sunflower seed vegan “cheese”. A thin crust topped with generous dollops off fresh plum tomato sauce. Finished off with imported EVOO from Italy, oregano and fresh Basil.

Pros: vegan options, authentic NY pizza

exaltedflesh_

Points +251

Vegan
03 Oct 2019

Favorite vegan pizza in NY

Although this isn’t a vegan establishment, this is easily one of the best vegan pizzas I’ve ever had. They usually have 2-4 vegan options per day.

Poundie

Points +15256

Vegan
30 Sep 2019

Good vegan pizza

This is a top-rated pizza place with a bunch of vegan options--not just "no cheese pizza," but slices with vegan cheese and vegan faux-meats (there were five separate vegan options when I stopped by). It is next to a Flix but stop and fight by Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. This is a very traffic-filled, busy spot of NYC that I avoid unless I have to be nearby--but if you are in the area and like pizza, this is a good place to check out.

Updated from previous review on 2019-09-30

Pros: Good vegan pizza

Cons: Not super-healthy., Trafficy part of NYC




This page has been viewed 12913 times.