Lacto
Pizza
Italian
Beer/Wine
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Pizza restaurant. Has vegan cheese and crust. Build your own option. Relocated from
7531 S Virginia Dare Trail. Open Mon-Sun 3:00pm-9:00pm.


Venue map for Nags Head Pizza Company
© OpenStreetMap contributors

31 Reviews

First Review by Ember

Madisonian

Points +1157

Vegan
27 Nov 2024

Great vegan pizza

Great find on the OBX. Vegan pizza options clearly marked on the menu. Veggies are fresh and flavorful and the thin-style crust is delicious.

May '24 update: We tried the Love Your Mother vegan pizza, with veg pepperoni and spicy pepper flakes. Delicious and generous portions.

Tried the Hayley's Comet on our last visit, with tofu, banana peppers and vegan pepperoni and cheese--excellent. Fast delivery as well.

Updated from previous review on 2024-05-07

Pros: Multiple vegan pizzas, Friendly staff, Tasty and fresh

libra.minx

Points +18

Vegan
17 Oct 2024

Great pizza

had the vegan pepperoni pizza and it was amazing! also got the surfin spoon lavender berry icecream sandwich from here, so good! service was great!

Pros: fully vegan pizza, tasty options, staff and atmosphere are great.

RiverOne

Points +145

Vegan
01 Oct 2024

Vegan Pizza

The pizza was great - and fast!

mostzy

Points +132

Vegan
31 Aug 2024

good vegan pizza options

ordered the daily dose with added vegan pepperoni

jettabutt

Points +32

Vegan
11 Aug 2024

One of the few places that offers a fully vegan pizza

They do offer a vegan cauliflower crust with vegan cheese. For toppings they have veggies, vegan pepperoni and tofu.

RobinBobbin

Points +145

Vegan
26 Jul 2024

Delicious

Husband and I stopped in for dinner and didn’t have to wait long at all for our pizza. Glad we picked a clear night because the only seating is outside. We split the Farmers Market veganized with vegan cheese. It had just enough cheese and the lightest touch of red sauce. If you love a lot of sauce, ask for extra. We also added the vegan pepperoni. It was a nice medium thick crust with tons of veggies.

Only complaint is that they wasted a box for use dining in rather than using a reusable tray.

Pros: Vegan cheese, Vegan pepperoni , Many vegetable options

Cons: Waste a box for dining in, Not indoor seating

SusanMarie

Points +23

Vegetarian
30 Jun 2024

Local yummy

We went vegan pepperoni and mushrooms on the other, and I wish we had put it all on one pizza. They’ve got yard games in the back and picnic tables in the front. Vegan cheese and gluten free and wine in a can options. We were hungry and ordered it ahead online, and it was ready when we pulled up.

Pros: Vegan pepperoni, Family beach atmosphere , Locally owned and all the local kids work here

Cons: I could see the picnic tables not working in rain, No nonalcoholic beers, Everything on OBX is a drive away

DrMichelle20

Points +501

Vegan
03 Jun 2024

Clearly labeled!

Great pizza, friendly staff, clearly labeled which items are vegan.

AddieAnneSmith

Points +380

Vegan
27 Mar 2024

Delicious Pizza

This is a great option for takeout. We got the Haley's Comet Pizza and the breadsticks. Everything was clearly marked as vegan. The woman that helped us was so friendly and calm. I would highly recommend this an option for dinner! And I loved the positive affirmations on the I side of the pizza boxes!

Updated from previous review on 2024-03-27

allenliu

Points +20

Mostly Veg
26 Nov 2023

Serviceable pizza

First off - I like that they have several vegan preset pizzas. I go the Hayley's comet. It was high in acidity due to the banana peppers, tomato slices, and sauce. Overall, it felt lacking in salt and sugar. I might've preferred a cheeseless domino's pie

Friendly service. No indoor seating, but I'm sure it's a lovely spot to hang in the summertime with picnic tables.

jenvth

Points +396

Vegan
22 Jul 2023

Vegan and vegetarian pizza options

Delicious vegan pepperoni pizza with a flavorful tomato sauce. Nice crispy thin crust. Would come here weekly if I didn’t live two hours away.

Pros: Great flavor, Quick service

Cons: A little pricey

Mirandawing6

Points +120

Vegan
18 Jul 2022

Best pizza

Loved this recommendation from happy cow! Great vegan pizza options which were also very tasty. Would definitely go again!

kristenohr

Points +16

Vegan
08 Jul 2022

Very good pizza enjoyed by all!

Many veggie toppings, as well as vegan pepperoni option.

CandiceThies

Points +42

Vegan
18 Mar 2022

Amazing for a non specialized vegan pizza company

We were craving pizza and found they had options. You never know what you're going to get with a non vegan specialized restaurant but this place was great. Be aware their red sauce has cheese in it, thankfully they told us when asking about vegan options.

Pros: Quality ingredients, Quality vegan cheese

Cons: Not a lot of options

KatieMcMahon

Points +221

Vegan
10 Sep 2021

Amazing pizza!! :)

Haven’t had vegan pizza before (that wasn’t from Blaze) so this was a super lovely treat😄Really loved the vegan pepperoni & the cute way they decorate their boxes!

Pros: Tasty, Not super expensive

chikp_lvr

Points +72

Vegan
21 Jun 2021

Excellent!!!

Thin crust pizza with vegan cheese and pepperoni! So easy and good. Just $20. Add salt for the cheese to pop.

KellyKramer

Points +281

Vegan
12 Jun 2021

Good vegan options

Had vegan cheese offering and vegan pepperoni and tofu. Super yummy and order came so fast. Still doing online ordering and payment so no dine in option yet but still great service

Pros: Good vegan options

kefox1995

Points +1100

Vegan
25 May 2021

Yummm!!!

This pizza was 9/10- missing the pizza sauce😒got missed from my order but otherwise the toppings were all so yummy and the cheese was great and melty. So many great options for vegans including pepperoni, tofu and endless veggies. You could also veganize the breadsticks and sometimes they have ice cream from Surfin Spoon

Pros: Vegan pepperoni and cheese , Great crust

Cons: Sauce was forgotten

CodyDenzler

Points +53

Vegan
05 Apr 2021

Nags Head Pizza is the pizza for you and me

I visit Nags Head often and Nags Head Pizza Company is always a must. They have plenty of vegan options. The staff is always super friendly and accommodating to vegans. The cheese they use is so good! They also have tofu and a mock pepperoni. I like to build my own with bbq sauce, tofu, onion, and pineapple 😋

Pros: Lot of vegan options, Super accommodating, Friendly staff

kimbarley

Points +126

Vegan
12 Oct 2020

Vegan pizza rocked!

Surprised to find vegan pizza options with vegan cheese and pepperoni! It was so good the non vegans in our party ate all our pizza!

Birgit

Points +1856

Vegan
27 Sep 2020

Vegan pizza and dessert

At this time they are only open for take out and delivery. And Yay they have vegetarian and vegan and build your own pizza. I had the Love Your Mother vegan pizza and it was delicious with a crispy crust and lots of fresh arugula on top. My absolute highlight was the vegan frozen ice cream sandwich. Lemon Luvberry with lemon cookie and blueberry and lavender ice cream. Organic too!!!! The best I had since ever.

Dessy

Points +45

Vegan
01 Sep 2020

AWESOME PIZZA!!!

VEGAN PIZZA!!!! Clearly labeled vegan items!!! We live in a big city and their vegan pizza is better than anything we can get at home. We got the Hayley's Comet and it was GREAT. Loaded with fresh veggies. Filling & fairly priced. I sooo appreciate when restaurants have a separate vegan section on their menu; I hate bringing attention to my diet (I just wanna have a pleasant, simple time eating out like everybody else) & clearly labeled menus mean I never have to a)ask a million questions or b)worry about staff saying something is vegan when it isn't - which happened to us at Waterfront Grill & happens....all the time. How nice that they make it so simple for vegan eaters!

Vegan cheese seems to be Daiya? Not sure, but that’s what it tasted like. Honestly, I think all these processed fake cheeses are nasty, but ultimately I’m just stoked they offer it bc lots of lactose-free people do like it. That said, they do give you the option for light or no cheese. We went with light cheese & it was fine in small Spears but the pizza would definitely be just as delicious & filling without.

So - pizza is 4 stars, but bumping to 5 stars because their COVID pick up situation is AWESOME & feels super safe, and their staff was so friendly and helpful. We will be back!

Pros: Vegan options clearly labeled, Option for light/no cheese, Loaded with fresh veggies!

Tarasellsohio

Points +26

Vegan
18 May 2020

Amazing pizza

Amazing pizza my husband ordered hayleys comet and love your mother’s. I did a build your own. My son is gluten free & got a gluten free one for him.

Pros: Amazing vegan pizza! , Fast delivery

Cons: None

jrfishe1

Points +448

Vegan
28 Oct 2019

Amazing pizza

We really didn't expect the pizza at a little beach town like this to be any good. But we were very pleasantly surprised! The vegan pepperoni was amazing, the crust was really good, the sauce was good, and the pizza we had had lots of delicious fresh garlic and onion. Overall we really enjoyed it and would come back any time we were nearby!

Pros: Amazing vegan pepperoni, Great crust

Jessicaaaaaaaaa

Points +141

Vegan
12 May 2019

Good vegan 🍕

Good vegan pizza!

HappyLamp

Points +74

Vegan
20 Jul 2018

Good

A ton of veggies to choose from, vegan cheese options. Not the best vegan pizza I’ve ever had, but it was really good.

Pros: Lots of vegan options

Cons: Slightly expensive

Ember

Points +163

Vegan
03 Jul 2018

great pizza!

Picked this place out after seeing it on Happy Cow. I'm proud to put in the first review! They use Daiya cheese for vegans, their crust is vegan friendly, and they have a good list of topping options. The crust was thin and crispy and the sauce had great flavor. By far the best vegan pizza I've ever had! Staff was polite and nice, and I even had a nice conversation with someone working there about vegan food. I plan to make this a regular stop whenever I'm in the Outer Banks!

P.S. If it's nice outside, enjoy your pizza with a great waterfront view!

Updated from previous review on 2017-05-13

Pros: delicious pizza!, nice staff, good prices




This page has been viewed 5208 times.