• Herrell's Ice Cream

  • (12)
    7
    Loading...
  • Ice-cream Ice Cream

Dairy ice cream shop that offers four vegan flavours (No-Moo) made from a cashew-almond base which rotate over time. Vegan milkshakes made from No-Moo and soy milk are also available. The chocolate sprinkles are reportedly vegan. Open Mon-Thu 12:00pm-10:00pm, Fri-Sat 12:00pm-11:00pm, Sun 12:00pm-10:00pm.


Venue map for Herrell's Ice Cream
© OpenStreetMap contributors

12 Reviews

First Review by conniex721

hannah921

Points +69

Vegan
31 Jul 2024

Eh

The vegan ice cream can be icey... It’s kinda hit or miss with that unfortunately. Hopefully they keep working on their formula.

lulutmlnsn

Points +243

Vegan
11 Dec 2023

yum !

i got a small no - moo vanilla scoop w some shaved almonds on top. nice and simple j how i like it !! i love tht the texture is more icy than creamy. i like tht. employee was rly sweet and i didnt get a weird look when i asked if it was vegan. cool spot and i wanna come back !

update 2 months later : i called ahead before coming in with my dad to ask which vegan flavours they would have for this upcoming weekend and the girl on the phone was so sweet and helpful. im looking forward 2 bringing my dad here and will update then !!☺️

Updated from previous review on 2023-11-12

Pros: yummy yummyyy, very kind, upbeat staff, cute spot

kale_queen

Points +474

Vegan
30 May 2023

Okay

I’m glad they have vegan options but I wish the vegan ice cream were a little less icy.

Sarah P

Points +8720

Vegan
27 Jul 2022

Yummy No-Moo

I love Herrell's No-Moo and am never disappointed. I also love that the chocolate sprinkles are vegan. I tried a No-Moo shake once and wasn’t impressed, but I’ve loved everything else I’ve had here from the No-Moo menu.

Updated from previous review on 2013-09-24

Pros: Free birthday sundae- or vegan equivalent, Nice flavor choices , Vegan chocolate sprinkles

Audj

Points +137

Vegan
02 Nov 2021

Vegan accessible, never having to be left out of an ice cream outing

Vegan accessible, never left out of an iced cream outing!!

MJStanley

Points +28

Vegan
04 Jul 2021

Not my cone of ice cream

Herrell"s is disappointing.
I do not like the texture.

But I applaud them for trying to provide an alternative to dairy.

SeciliaFeliz

Points +58

Vegan
14 Aug 2020

Not Good

Went to Herrell's today for the first time and it was very underwhelming. We had the No-Moo Vanilla Cookie and it was stringy and tasted like tapioca. Also those were not real chocolate chip cookie pieces. We have had Sheldon's Ice Cream in Southampton and they are 100 times better. We will stick to Sheldon's from now on.

Cons: Not a lot of vegan options

emilyy_wells

Points +213

Vegan
24 Nov 2019

amazing

my non-veg friend and i went here and absolutely loved it!! she had a regular burnt sugar and butter dairy ice-cream and i had the vegan, gf ice-cream sandwich! 10/10 would recommend!!

Pros: several vegan options , reasonably priced , gluten-free options!!

mbordewieck

Points +218

Vegan
20 Oct 2019

Eh. No moo is pretty bad.

The sorbet options are great, but No-moo is really lackluster (stringy? Not creamy) compared to most vegan ice creams out there.

HaleyMoriarty

Points +242

Vegan
20 Aug 2019

not creamy but it’ll do

their no-moo ice cream has a good flavor, but the texture isn’t as good as other ice creams. it’s less creamy and more gritty/frozen. however, it’s nice to get ice cream with your friends and have an option! they also label all the cones that are vegan (which I think are all of them). the no-moo flavors rotate and they usually have 3-5 at a time.

Pros: vegan options, labels

Cons: not the best texture

pinkplushdino

Points +56

Vegan
14 Apr 2013

real tasting ice cream!

If you're sick of sorbet, this is a great place to find yourself. They only offer two flavors of the cashew cream, but they're never boring or odd tasting. If you dig seasonal flavors, watch out for frequent showings of the pumpkin walnut flavor in the fall. They also make several different flavors, which keeps you coming in to try new ones. Personally, I thought the prices were fair, but it is cash only.

Pros: not sorbet, creative flavors

Cons: cash only

conniex721

Points +136

Vegan
27 May 2012

Nice to Have an Option

It's wonderful to be able to go out with non-vegan friends for ice cream and not have to get sorbet. Of course, I wish there were more than two flavors, but just the fact that it's something other than vanilla or chocolate is great. The ice cream is almond and cashew based, so if you're watching out for soy you're in the clear. Also, the famous chocolate sprinkles are vegan! (You have to get the sprinkles, they're free!). All in all, a nice option.

Finally, the prices are a little steep.

Pros: Tasty, Fun Flavors

Cons: Expensive




This page has been viewed 0 times.