Yummy pizza loaded with unlimited toppings! $1 extra for meat substitutes. at Create A Pizza in Rochester
Garlic knots! 4 for $1 at Create A Pizza in Rochester
Vegan pizza with vegan pesto at Create A Pizza in Rochester

  • Create A Pizza
    (13)
    8
    Loading...
  • White Veg-options
Lacto
Ovo
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Take-out
Non-veg

Serves meat, vegan options available. Build-your-own pizza restaurant with some seating. Has vegan cheese and beyond meat as toppings. Open Tue-Wed 12:00pm-9:00pm, Thu 12:00pm-7:00pm, Fri-Sat 12:00pm-9:00pm, Sun 1:00pm-8:00pm. Closed Mon.

Venue map for Create A Pizza
© OpenStreetMap contributors

13 Reviews

First Review by TracyWeb

Avatar static175

static175

Points +629

Vegan
31 Aug 2024

Great pizza

Great pizza, lots of options, super fast, friendly owners, good prices, and clearly marked vegan. They also use grassfed pepperoni which is cool.

Pros: Good prices, Friendly, Lots of options

Cheese stix at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Personnel with grassfed pepperoni at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar FESlade

FESlade

Points +26

Vegan
19 May 2024

Favorite pizza place

Love this shop and that all the sauces are vegan. A vegan version of the sweet and saucy pizza is a personal favorite.

Pros: Toppings, Staff, Value

Avatar lizardlucas

lizardlucas

Points +1142

Vegan
25 Sep 2023

Surprised me

I had heard really good things about this place, and I kind of lumped it in with similar chains thinking it would be decent but not something to write home about. Not so. They have multiple vegan cheese and fake meat options, including grass fed's pepperoni. They even have red fern bleu cheese and ranch sauces available!

To top it off, our order literally came out of the oven as we were picking it up, so it was incredibly hot and fresh. We only tried a calzone the first time but that cheesy garlic bread is definitely up next.

The one thing that is slightly frustrating is when ordering online, there's a "make it vegan" section at the top. Unfortunately, if you select a cheese there, you'll be charged double because there's no "no cheese" option for the normal cheese selection area below. So you choose your fake meats from the make it vegan section, and then select your cheese in the normal cheese selector.

Pros: Great food, Good prices , Friendly staff

Cons: Confusing online ordering

Avatar SusanneCollins

SusanneCollins

Points +25

Vegan
27 Aug 2023

Tons of vegan options! Amazing food!!

I thought this place might be one of the spots that only has one vegan cheese. But this place has TONS of options! Three different vegan cheezes, a half dozen vegan meat options, and all the sauces are vegan. It is family owned as well and the owners are SO nice. Definitely stop by if you can! This spot has more options for vegans than some fully vegan pizza places I’ve been to! I wish I could give them five stars but apparently happy cow only allows that for fully veg establishments….

Avatar magoo1994

magoo1994

Points +24

Vegan
01 Apr 2023

Five stars!!! Amazing vegan options!!

This family run pizza joint is perfect for vegans—you can customize any kind of pie you want!!
All sauce bases are vegan (including pesto, Buffalo, garlic butter, and more!)
They have 3 kinds of vegan cheese and 6 kinds of vegan meat (some homemade!)

The owners are super friendly and very accommodating for vegans :)

Our favorite is the Buffalo sauce!!

Pros: Lots of vegan cheese, Plenty of vegan meats, Affordable

Cons: None

This is a fully vegan pizza, 12 inch, buffalo sauce, two types of vegan cheese (Numu and Tofu Ricotta) with all vegetable toppings. at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar GbTheQueen

GbTheQueen

Points +269

Vegan
21 Oct 2022

Great vegan pepperoni

I love their vegan pepperoni amazing on the pizza. I love a good build your own pizza at a great price. Can’t go wrong with some delicious vegan pepperoni and vegan cheese. Yummy.

Pros: Vegan pepperoni , Vegan cheese, Build your own

Avatar supabush

supabush

Points +935

Vegan
09 Apr 2022

Delicious Vegan Pizza that is actually affordable!

I was craving a calzone and it can be hard to find a place with good vegan options. Create A Pizza did not let me down! They not only have several options for vegan mozzarella, they also have a vegan ricotta which I think really makes a great calzone! The pricing is very fair, and you're not over charged for getting a vegan option. I got a decent size calzone for around $10 which had two types of vegan cheese, vegan meatballs and lots of veggies! It was absolutely delicious, I loved their crust and cheese and all together with the veggies and meatballs it was just amazing. I then got a pizza the next time and was pleasantly surprised again. They have tons of unique options for vegans, and the numu cheese option was super tasty! This will be a new regular for my pizza cravings! If you're in Rochester and you need some pizza, definitely check them out!

Updated from previous review on 2022-04-09

Pros: Great pricing, Lots of vegan cheese/meat options, Yummy crust and fresh toppings!

Create a calzone with vegan ricotta and vegan mozz at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Create a clazone! at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Create a pizza at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Pizza with nomu cheese at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Create a pizza with nomu cheese, mushroom bacon, olives, pineapple, mushrooms and red onion! So good! at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar faith125brown

faith125brown

Points +297

Vegan
17 Jul 2021

Love this pizza shop!

Lots of fresh veggies, with a couple vegan cheese options and vegan meat options. The desert pizza with icing is vegan but Nutella is not.

Pros: Vegan meat and cheese options, Fast, Friendly staff

Thin crust but you’re able to ask for thicker at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar juls

juls

Points +43

Vegan
01 May 2020

Yum!

Was so excited to find a pizza place close by that had so many vegan options. Up to 14 free veggies can be added.

Pros: Lots of vegan options!, Veggies were fresh

Avatar amc1227

amc1227

Points +20

Vegan
09 Mar 2020

Would rate 5 stars if allowed by the app!

Wonderful pizza place, they have the full spectrum of vegan options. they have two options of vegan cheese (daiya and follow your heart), plus vegan sausage, meatballs, and bacon!
I created my own pizza with vegan cheese sausage caramelized onions mushrooms and olives, and it was wonderful especially with the balsamic finishing sauce! The staff was also very friendly. (I would rate this place five stars but happy cow will only let you rate vegan or vegetarian restaurants as five stars)

Pros: Multiple vegan options, Great crust and sauce

vegan sausage and cheese! at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar pickflowersnotfights

pickflowersnotfights

Points +66

Vegan
23 Aug 2019

Yum

Can’t beat four vegan garlic knots for $1. Would leave a 5 star review but happy cow won’t let me. Staff all knew what vegan meant. Unlimited vegetable toppings 👍🏼

Cheap vegan garlic knots! Sweet! at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar VeggieMo

VeggieMo

Points +34

Vegan
21 Aug 2019

Fun Vegan Pizza with Unlimited Toppings

It’s so nice to have an easy place to pick up real pizza that’s vegan! It’s also fun because you build your pizza as they make it. They are always adding to their vegan toppings. They have meat substitutes for sausage and meatballs, and also a ‘bacon’ topping. Also, vegan pesto sauce and loads of veggies to choose from, and 2 kinds of vegan cheese! The staff is very friendly.

Pros: Lots of vegan toppings!, Friendly staff., Close to the highway and there’s a parking lot.

Yummy pizza loaded with unlimited toppings! $1 extra for meat substitutes. at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Avatar TracyWeb

TracyWeb

Points +743

Vegan
28 Jun 2019

Delicious!

Create a pizza has a a huge selection of vegan items to add to your pizza. Lots of veggies, sauces as well as vegan cheeses and meats. They have dai ya cheese as well as follow your heart. The owner not only has beyond sausages but also makes meatballs and vegan pepperoni ( mushroom based). Oh and the garlic knots are vegan and are absolutely amazing!

Pros: Make their own vegan meatballs and pepperoni , Garlic knots!! SO GOOD, Owner wants to continue expanding the vegan menu

Garlic/oil with lots of veggies as well as beyond meat sausage. at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Garlic knots! 4 for $1 at Create A Pizza in Rochester

Write Review Update Listing
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policy
For Business Owners

Claim this business

See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditions

This page has been viewed 0 times.