Veganism is extremism? I came across an article in the UK press that has used veganism as an analogy to Islamic extremism of the sort that lead to the attempted Christmas bombing in Detroit. Now, care must be taken to point out that this is slightly out of context, as the author of this article was trying to highlight the attitude of University students as they search to establish their identity separate from their peers and their parents are highly susceptible to attaching themselves to a ‘radical’ movement. Whether this is socialism, environmentalism or veganism. However, there are always some bad apple extra-curricular activities students can get involved with. Like the British National Party here in the UK – a political party whose policies are defined by racism, intolerance and bigotry. And as the press is latching onto and sensationalizing, Universities can also be seen as recruitment grounds for Islamic terrorists. Preying on a students need to belong to something outside of the fringes of what their parents world was built upon.
You can read the original article in it’s entirety here.
Not wanting to get into a debate on politics or religion, let’s look again at that opening sentence: is veganism extremism? The analogy interestingly frames both Islamic extremism and veganism as comparative equals, however, the word extremism is now so linked to terrorism and violence that it can’t be any further from the beliefs held by vegans. And although distinctly different in practice and ideology, by linking them through analogy all kinds of negative connotations come to mind. So, no, based on the current view on extremism, veganism is not extremism.
But not only is veganism portrayed as being ‘bad’ it’s also put forward as impermanent. So next question, is veganism a fad or a a form of rebellion? It’s difficult to quantify the truth of this statement as statistics are sketchy, depending on where you go the numbers are all slightly different. However, all sources seem to agree that the number of people adopting a vegan or vegetarian lifestyle is on the rise. (If you want to see for yourself Google ‘vegan statistics’) Current numbers from selected segments of the population in the UK and the USA both show numbers ranging from 2-5% of the respective population are vegan or vegetarian, so although a minority, vegan is not a drastic or immoderate lifestyle. The temptation is to look at fruitarians or freegans when looking for food extremes, but even here, these is no need to point fingers to label someone different. Tolerance and acceptance of personal choice and individual freedoms is necessary for all people, so long as their choices don’t harm others. You want to eat only fruit, eat only fruit. You don’t want to be vegan, don’t be vegan. Everyone needs to make the decisions that are best for them. Stereotypes and assumptions lead to comparisons between people who are defined by compassion and moral conviction with people who are defined by violence and death. And that is not right.
4 Comments
JohnnySensible (31 comments)
January 19, 2010 at 7:01 pmThere was another article in the same paper recently – which was equally badly written – http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jan/18/five-fatal-flaws-animal-activism – Victor Schonfeld displaying his fundamentalist stance. ‘Telling’ adult females how to behave & casting slurs on activists. From his choice of language it seems that he is little more than a Francione clone!
Trying to speak for others / craving ‘position’ in the veg*n world is a sadlife game!
The Guardian publishes some fine articles also – I guess that these trashy ones appear to appease milk / egg / meat addicted readers!
Chia (324 comments)
February 17, 2010 at 8:54 pmIs veganism extremism? In my opinion, it can be but usually is not. So, yes and no.
I’ve come across a range of vegans with differing attitudes about their lifestyle choice. There are the minority of very strict and radical vegans who tend to preach too much about it to others, and they give off an “holier than thou” attitude.
And there are the majority of vegans who are just doing their part to create a more just, peaceful, and healthier life through veganism.
Most meat-eaters I know feel somewhat threatened and will get defensive when they come into contact with a person who does not eat animal flesh.
Typical human behavior, I guess.
gurcani (1 comments)
February 28, 2010 at 12:42 pmIt is.
Unless you are vegan for “health reasons”.
When compassion to animals (especially their intrinsic rights) contradicts with the imposed rules of the society, as an ethical vegan you find yourself with a choice to make. If you make the choice that they don’t like. You are in trouble.
It may be just saving a dolphin from a government lab, or damaging a slaughterhouse (which, to some of us is not so different, ethically, from “damaging” the Auschwitz).
http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/05/19/domestic.terrorism/
Here is the FBI’s page for the “most wanted” domestic terrorists. 4 of the 9 people in this list are basically animal liberation people.
http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/fugitives/dt/fug_dt.htm
So be warned. Your views are seen by a large chunk of the society as extremism. It is up to you to decide if you are proud or ashamed of this fact.
10 Ways To Lead Your College Vegan Club To Success | Your Vegetarian Kitchen
April 7, 2015 at 11:21 am[…] guide to going veg*n Promoting Veganism YOUR Way How To Really Talk To People About Being Vegan Veganism is extremism? var hupso_services_t=new Array("Twitter","Facebook","Google […]